The boards were technically on the v2 tokens (Source Serif + Forma DJR + navy + plum) but reading like a generic-clean events app — the v1 feeling. The reason: a cold grey ground, flat hairline boxes, grey "placeholder" tiles, and small type strip out exactly what makes the v2 website feel like The Lineup. Here's the diagnosis, and the Today home rebuilt to carry the v2 soul without re-bloating the density.
Grounded in the approved v2 website (the homepage + the redesign): the app had the right tokens but the wrong treatment. Each row is a lever I can pull across all the app surfaces.
| v1-feeling (what it was) | v2 soul (the fix) |
| Cold grey ground (#FAFBFC) | Warm paper + whisper of grain |
| Flat hairline rectangle cards | Accent-framed photos · warm editorial cards · one navy band |
| Grey "placeholder" tiles (read as empty) | Confident full-color sigils as brand texture |
| Photos absent or flat gradient boxes | The few images get the frame-forward editorial treatment |
| Small, uniform type — utility | Bigger serif voice moments · editorial gravitas |
| All-light, even, "an events app" | Light/paper + a navy editorial beat — "a local publication" |
The density redesign pulls toward fewer/smaller images (clean utility); the v2 soul pulls toward photographic + editorial. They felt opposed — which is how the boards drifted. The resolution: the soul lives in treatment (warmth, the framed hero, confident sigils, the navy beat, serif), not in volume — so we keep the lean density and get the v2 feel. If this is the right direction, I'll re-skin the nav+home boards (and carry it to Where-to-Go + onboarding) to this treatment before handing to APP. One open call for you: how far toward the navy/editorial end do you want the app to lean — this balance (paper-led, one navy beat), or bolder (more navy, like the web homepage)?